?

Log in

No account? Create an account
wshaffer
Book Review: Player of Games by Iain M. Banks 
21st-Jul-2013 08:37 pm
logical
The Player of Games (Culture, #2)The Player of Games by Iain M. Banks

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


When I first read it, over a decade ago, Player of Games was not my favorite Culture novel. In fact, it was my second least-favorite, ranking just above Excession. Not that it was a bad book, by any means, but I felt that, in the Empire of Azad, Banks had created a ridiculous caricature of a xenophobic, militaristic, authoritarian, sexist society, and used it as a rather smug way of proving the moral superiority of the Culture.

I don't find the Empire of Azad nearly so ridiculous any longer. I still think there are a few places in which Banks over-eggs things a bit in terms of convincing the reader that the Azadians are really horrible, but overall, they're entirely plausible.

More importantly, I see the book less as a smug exercise in demonstrating the superiority of the Culture than as an attempt to address two philosophical objections to post-scarcity societies like the Culture: first, the idea that in such societies, life lacks purpose because people don't have to struggle for existence; and second, the idea that a peaceful, consensus-driven society like the Culture will always be defeated by a warlike authoritarian society because the inhabitants of the warlike society have greater will and fortitude in defending their ideas. It's still preaching the choir (at least for a reader like me), but at least it's a more complex point than, "Genocide, torture, and sexism are bad, okay?"

I still don't think that this will end up being my favorite Culture novel when I've finished this re-read, but it's a better book than I'd given it credit for. I'm really curious to see whether my reaction to Excession will change, but I've got a few books to read before I get there.



View all my reviews
Comments 
22nd-Jul-2013 03:17 pm (UTC)
That's a really interesting point - this may be the only book that really addresses the fact that Special Circumstances, in particular, can't always function as the kind of all-volunteer free-and-open source war and diplomacy operation that it sometimes appears to be. I'll have to keep an eye out for that in future books.
This page was loaded Aug 23rd 2019, 10:58 am GMT.